'American Idol' Prediction Results: We Didn't See it Coming Either, James Durbin

Sometimes we "Idol" prognosticators get it totally right and then there's this week.
All around, we couldn't have been more wrong about what was going to happen on Thursday night's "American Idol" elimination show. After all the Haley Reinhart talk and the certainty that the blues grunter would be sent back to Chicago (where there [...]

Anouk Elisabetta Canalis Barry Williams Sophie Anderton