'American Idol' Prediction Results: We Feel Haley Reinhart's Pain

The math just doesn't add up. Three contestants, two of them Southern church charmers who sing country music, and one Northerner who belts bluesy rock and has the underdog mantle.
But, somehow, Haley Reinhart stumbled one last time amid a record-setting 95 million vote landslide that pushed charming teens Lauren Alaina and Scotty McCreery into [...]

Ethel Barrymore Maximilian Schell Gregg Sulkin Marlene Favela